How Much Can You Rent Your Home For?
If you're having trouble selling your home in today's market, renting it out may be worth considering.
I've had conversations with homeowners who are sitting on a property that isn't getting the offers they expected. Sometimes the problem is the price. Sometimes it's the market. And sometimes, the best move is simply to stop trying to force a sale and look at the numbers from a different angle.
Could renting your home out for a year or two make more sense than selling it today?
Maybe.
But the first question I usually get is: "How much can I rent my house for?"
The answer isn't always as simple as looking at what your neighbour is asking. Getting the right rental price is important. Price it too high and your property could sit vacant. Price it too low and you're leaving money on the table.
Here's how I would approach it.
Start With the Market, Not Your Mortgage
One of the biggest mistakes I see homeowners make is basing their rental price on what they need to make each month.
I understand why. If your mortgage, property taxes, insurance and other expenses add up to $3,000 a month, it's tempting to think, "I need to rent it for $3,000."
Unfortunately, the rental market doesn't care what your expenses are.
Your home is worth what qualified tenants are willing to pay for it in the current market.
That means you need to look at comparable rental properties in your area. Ideally, you're comparing homes that are similar in:
Location
Number of bedrooms and bathrooms
Overall condition
Square footage
Parking
Basement or additional living space
Yard and outdoor space
Appliances
Utilities included or not included
Furnished vs. unfurnished
Pet policies
A three-bedroom home in Kingston is not automatically worth the same rent as every other three-bedroom home in Kingston.
The condition of the home, the neighbourhood and the features all matter.
How Do You Find the Right Market Rent?
I recommend looking at what similar properties are actually renting for, not just what other landlords are asking.
There's a difference.
You might see five similar homes advertised at $2,800 a month. That doesn't necessarily mean they're all renting for $2,800. Some may have been sitting on the market for weeks. Others may have reduced their price.
The goal is to find the sweet spot.
You want a rental price that:
Attracts qualified tenants.
Gives you a strong return on your investment.
Doesn't create unnecessary vacancy.
For example, if you price your property $200 above market and it sits vacant for two months, you've lost $4,000 in potential rental income.
Was that extra $200 a month worth it?
Probably not.
This is one of those situations where trying to get the absolute highest monthly rent can actually cost you money.
Don't Just Look for a Tenant. Look for the Right Tenant.
This is where things can get complicated.
Finding someone who wants to rent your home is relatively easy. Finding someone who is a good tenant is a different story.
When reviewing a potential tenant, you want to look at things like:
Employment and income
Rental history
Credit history
References
Previous landlord feedback
Number of occupants
Pets
Overall ability to meet the lease obligations
You also need to make sure you're following Ontario's rules when screening applicants. There are legal restrictions around what landlords can ask and how rental applications are handled.
And this is where I think many first-time landlords underestimate the job.
A tenant may look great on paper. They have a good income and a decent credit score. But what about their rental history? Did they pay on time? Did they take care of the property? Did they leave the home in good condition?
The cheapest tenant is not always the best tenant.
A tenant who pays $100 less per month but takes excellent care of your property and pays on time may be a much better investment than someone who agrees to your full asking price but becomes a constant problem.
The Real Cost of a Bad Tenant
Most people think property management is about collecting rent.
It's not.
It's about managing risk.
A bad tenant can create costs that go well beyond a missed rent payment. You could be dealing with property damage, maintenance issues, complaints from neighbours, unpaid rent or the legal process involved in resolving a tenancy dispute.
And then there's your time.
If you have a full-time job, a family and your own life to manage, do you really want to be answering a tenant's maintenance call at 10 p.m.?
Probably not.
This is one of the biggest reasons I believe professional property management can make sense for many homeowners.
Why Use a Property Manager?
A good property manager should help you with much more than collecting rent.
The goal should be to protect your property, reduce your risk, minimize vacancy and make owning a rental property easier.
Depending on the service, that can include:
Determining the right market rent
Marketing the property
Showing the property
Screening prospective tenants
Preparing and managing the lease
Collecting rent
Handling maintenance requests
Coordinating repairs
Conducting property inspections
Managing lease renewals
Keeping records and providing owner updates
The biggest benefit, in my opinion, is having someone between you and the day-to-day problems.
If something goes wrong, you have someone to deal with it.
That doesn't mean property management eliminates every problem. It doesn't. But having a professional process in place can make a big difference.
Should You Rent or Sell Your Home?
This is the bigger question.
If your home isn't selling, renting it out can sometimes give you another option.
Instead of selling at a price you're not comfortable with, you may be able to rent the property, generate income and wait for a better time to sell.
But you need to run the numbers first.
Consider:
Expected monthly rent
Mortgage payments
Property taxes
Insurance
Maintenance and repairs
Property management costs
Vacancy periods
Potential future appreciation
Your personal financial situation
You also need to understand the rules and tax implications of converting a principal residence into a rental property. That's something you should discuss with your accountant before making a decision.
The important thing is to look at the property as an investment decision rather than simply thinking, "I can't sell it, so I'll rent it."
Those are two very different things.
My Advice to Homeowners
If you're thinking about renting your home, don't start by putting up an ad and hoping for the best.
Start with the numbers.
Find out what your property could realistically rent for. Look at the potential income and expenses. Then decide whether the investment makes sense.
And if you're not comfortable dealing with tenants, maintenance, inspections and the legal side of being a landlord, talk to a property manager before you make the decision.
Sometimes the best option is to manage the property yourself.
Sometimes it's worth paying a professional to handle it.
The important thing is knowing the difference.
The Bottom Line
If your home isn't selling in the current market, renting it out could be a smart alternative—but only if the numbers work.
The right rental price can help you attract good tenants while minimizing vacancy. The right tenant can protect your property and your investment. And the right property manager can take much of the day-to-day work off your plate.
If you're wondering "How much can I rent my home for in Kingston?", I'd be happy to take a look at your property and give you an idea of what the current rental market looks like.
Sometimes, knowing your options is the first step toward making the right decision.
Comments
Post a Comment